Tuesday, June 4, 2019

Presiding: Mayor Tom Butt · Called to order: 6:31 p.m. · 10 items · 20 votes · 19 public comments

What happened

  • Received the proposed 2019-20 city budget with 5 public comments but took no vote.
  • Rejected appointments to Rent Board, Police Review Commission, and Planning Commission 6-1 (Butt dissenting).
  • Rejected increasing payment limit to $240,000 for Point Molate environmental law firm with multiple abstentions.
  • Approved consent calendar including $1.02 million bike share grant and $54,000 environmental grants to nonprofits.
  • Approved weekly budget meetings to eliminate deficit and reestablishing school district coordination committee.

Auto-generated summary from agenda items and vote records

View official: Minutes

Attendance

Tom Butt(Present)
Ben Choi(Present)
Demnlus Johnson III(Present)
Eduardo Martinez(Present)
Jael Myrick(Present)
Melvin Willis(Present)
Nat Bates(Present)
10 substantive items · 11 consent

Appointments(1 item)

Appoint members to Rent Board, Police Review Commission, and Planning Commission

3-3Police & Community Safety

In Plain English

The city fills vacant seats on 3 boards that help govern Richmond. The Rent Board handles tenant-landlord disputes and sets rent control rules. The Police Review Commission investigates complaints against officers. The Planning Commission reviews new development projects and zoning changes.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

to approve all of the appointments

Moved by: Jael MyrickSeconded by: Demnlus Johnson III
Failed

3 to 3

Demnlus Johnson IIIAye
Jael MyrickAye
Tom ButtAye
Eduardo MartinezNay
Melvin WillisNay
Ben ChoiNay
Nathaniel BatesAbstain

to appoint members of the Community Police Review Commission and the reappointments to the Rent Board

Moved by: Eduardo MartinezSeconded by: Melvin Willis
Failed

5 to 1

Demnlus Johnson IIIAye
Eduardo MartinezAye
Jael MyrickAye
Melvin WillisAye
Ben ChoiAye
Tom ButtNay
Nathaniel BatesAbstain

to approve appointments to members of the Community Police Review Commission

Moved by: Nathaniel BatesSeconded by: Melvin Willis
Failed

6 to 1

Demnlus Johnson IIIAye
Eduardo MartinezAye
Jael MyrickAye
Melvin WillisAye
Ben ChoiAye
Tom ButtNay
Nathaniel BatesAye

to approve the appointments to the Community Police Review Commission and all of the reappointments to the other commissions

Moved by: Jael MyrickSeconded by: Melvin Willis
Failed

6 to 1

Demnlus Johnson IIIAye
Eduardo MartinezAye
Jael MyrickAye
Melvin WillisAye
Ben ChoiAye
Tom ButtNay
Nathaniel BatesAye

Governance(3 items)

Create master list of all city fees in one law

Master Fee Schedule

In Plain English

The city currently has fees scattered across different laws and departments. This creates a single document listing all fees the city charges for permits, licenses, and services. If approved, residents and businesses can find all fee information in one place instead of searching multiple sources.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

adopted Ordinance No. 8-19 N.S.

Moved by: Eduardo MartinezSeconded by: Melvin Willis
Passed

7 to 0

Nathaniel BatesAye
Tom ButtAye
Ben ChoiAye
Demnlus Johnson IIIAye
Eduardo MartinezAye
Jael MyrickAye
Melvin WillisAye

Change quorum rules for Citizens Police Review Commission meetings

6-1Police & Community Safety

In Plain English

The Citizens Police Review Commission currently cannot meet when commissioner seats are vacant because quorum rules require a fixed number of members. The proposed change calculates quorum based on how many commissioners are actually appointed rather than total possible seats. This ensures the commission can continue reviewing police matters even when some positions remain unfilled.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

approved the item with amendment that Citizens Police Review Commission be included in process of revisions to ordinance

Moved by: Eduardo MartinezSeconded by: Jael Myrick
Passed

6 to 1

Demnlus Johnson IIIAye
Eduardo MartinezAye
Jael MyrickAye
Melvin WillisAye
Ben ChoiAye
Tom ButtNay
Nathaniel BatesAye

Consider reestablishing coordination committee with West Contra Costa school district

Police & Community Safety

In Plain English

The city previously had a joint committee with the local school district to coordinate on shared issues. This committee no longer exists. If approved, city and school officials would meet regularly to discuss projects affecting both organizations like traffic safety near schools and shared facility use.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

to appoint Councilmembers Martinez and Johnson to an ad-hoc committee

Moved by: Nathaniel BatesSeconded by: Melvin Willis
Failed

to create an ad-hoc committee

Moved by: Eduardo MartinezSeconded by: Melvin Willis
Passed

7 to 0

Tom ButtAye
Ben ChoiAye
Demnlus Johnson IIIAye
Eduardo MartinezAye
Jael MyrickAye
Melvin WillisAye
Nathaniel BatesAye

Budget(4 items)

Receive proposed city budget for fiscal year 2019-20

FY 2019-20 Budget

In Plain English

The city manager presents the proposed spending plan for the fiscal year starting July 1, 2019. City council reviews the balanced budget and discusses priority items before final approval. The budget sets spending levels for all city services including police, parks, and infrastructure for the coming year.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Approve 3% increase in Hilltop neighborhood landscaping fees for 2019-2020

The Hilltop

In Plain English

Property owners in the Hilltop area pay annual assessments to maintain landscaping in their neighborhood. The city must formally approve these fees each year based on an engineer's cost analysis. If approved, your assessment increases by 3% for the upcoming fiscal year.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Approve 3% increase in Marina Bay landscaping fees for 2019-2020

Ford Point & Richmond Village

In Plain English

Marina Bay property owners pay special assessments to maintain landscaping and lighting in their neighborhood. The city engineer reviewed costs and recommends raising the assessment by 3% for the upcoming fiscal year. If approved, your annual landscaping fee increases slightly to cover rising maintenance costs.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Direct city manager to hold weekly budget meetings to eliminate deficit

Budget Deficit

In Plain English

The city faces a budget deficit that needs to be resolved. The proposed meetings would include department heads, union representatives, and up to 3 council members. If approved, they meet weekly to find ways to balance the budget while protecting city employee jobs and benefits.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

approved the item

Moved by: Melvin WillisSeconded by: Demnlus Johnson III
Passed

7 to 0

Tom ButtAye
Ben ChoiAye
Demnlus Johnson IIIAye
Eduardo MartinezAye
Jael MyrickAye
Melvin WillisAye
Nathaniel BatesAye

Contracts(2 items)

Amend contract with Vigilant Solutions for $30,000 through 2022

Police & Community Safety

In Plain English

The city has an existing contract with Vigilant Solutions that runs from 2019 to 2022. This amendment adds $30,000 to the contract value. Without the staff report, the specific services Vigilant Solutions provides are unclear, but the company typically offers license plate recognition and surveillance technology to law enforcement agencies.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Increase payment limit to $240,000 for Point Molate environmental law firm

Point Molate

In Plain English

The city hired Downey Brand LLP to handle environmental lawsuits related to Point Molate development. The original contract has a spending cap that needs to be raised. If approved, the city can pay up to $240,000 total for this legal work.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

to approve the item

Moved by: Ben ChoiSeconded by: Tom Butt
Failed

3 to 0

Nathaniel BatesAye
Ben ChoiAye
Tom ButtAye
Demnlus Johnson IIIAbstain
Eduardo MartinezAbstain
Jael MyrickAbstain
Melvin WillisAbstain

Approved as a group without individual discussion.