Tuesday, July 29, 2014

Special

Presiding: Mayor McLaughlin · Called to order: 5:47 p.m. · 9 items · 40 votes

What happened

  • Rejected budget and financial status report 4-3 (Bates, Boozé, Myrick, Rogers dissenting).
  • Rejected spending plan for North Richmond waste facility mitigation fees 2-3 (Bates, Boozé dissenting).
  • Approved Pacific States Environmental to clean contaminated Point Molate naval site 4-3 (Myrick, McLaughlin, Beckles dissenting).
  • Approved limiting councilmember question time during meetings 5-2 (Bates, Boozé dissenting).
  • Approved 19 routine items including $185,000 ShotSpotter contract and $175,000 public sculpture.

Auto-generated summary from agenda items and vote records

View official: Minutes

Attendance

Corky Boozé(Present)
Jael Myrick(Present)
Tom Butt(Present)
Jim Rogers(Absent)
Soheila Bana(Present)
Gayle McLaughlin(Present)
Jovanka Beckles(Absent)
10 substantive items · 19 consent · 3 procedural

Budget(3 items)

Approve spending plan for North Richmond waste facility mitigation fees

3-2North Richmond Waste Fees

In Plain English

The city collects fees from waste companies operating near North Richmond to offset impacts on residents. This plan directs how to spend the 2014/2015 fees on community improvements. If approved, the money funds projects like air quality monitoring or neighborhood cleanup programs.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

To overturn Mayor McLaughlin's ruling to not allow speakers and that the chairperson of the North Richmond Mitigation Fee Committee, Dr. Henry Clark, be allowed to give a 3-minute presentation

Moved by: Councilmember BatesSeconded by: Councilmember Boozé
Failed

3 to 2

Councilmember BoozéAye
Councilmember BatesAye
Mayor McLaughlinNay
Councilmember MyrickAye
Vice Mayor BecklesAbsent
Councilmember ButtNay
Councilmember RogersAbsent

To approve the expenditure plan and direct the City Manager to assist the Men and Women of Valor in finding other funding sources

Moved by: Councilmember ButtSeconded by: Mayor McLaughlin
Failed

3 to 2

Councilmember BoozéNay
Councilmember BatesNay
Mayor McLaughlinAye
Councilmember MyrickAye
Vice Mayor BecklesAbsent
Councilmember ButtAye
Councilmember RogersAbsent

Adopt report of sewer service charges for Fiscal Year 2014-15

Sewer Service Charges

In Plain English

The city must formally approve its annual report showing how much each property paid in sewer fees during the 2014-15 budget year. This routine administrative step documents sewer charges already collected from residents and businesses. The report does not change current sewer rates or create new fees.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

Closed the public hearing

Moved by: Councilmember MyrickSeconded by: Vice Mayor Beckles
Passed

7 to 0

Councilmember BoozéAye
Councilmember BatesAye
Mayor McLaughlinAye
Vice Mayor BecklesAye
Councilmember MyrickAye
Councilmember ButtAye
Councilmember RogersAye

Adopted Resolution No. 69-14

Moved by: Councilmember BoozéSeconded by: Councilmember Myrick
Passed

7 to 0

Councilmember BoozéAye
Councilmember BatesAye
Mayor McLaughlinAye
Vice Mayor BecklesAye
Councilmember MyrickAye
Councilmember ButtAye
Councilmember RogersAye

Receive budget and financial status report from finance director

3-4Quarterly Budget Report

In Plain English

The finance director presents the city's current financial condition to the council. This regular briefing covers revenue, expenses, and budget performance. The report helps residents understand how tax dollars are being spent and whether the city stays within its approved budget.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

To end debate

Moved by: Councilmember ButtSeconded by: Vice Mayor Beckles
Failed

3 to 4

Councilmember BoozéNay
Councilmember BatesNay
Mayor McLaughlinAye
Vice Mayor BecklesAye
Councilmember MyrickNay
Councilmember ButtAye
Councilmember RogersNay

Governance(5 items)

Add urgency item about Master Fee Schedule to tonight's agenda

Master Fee Schedule

In Plain English

The mayor and a council member want to discuss the city's Master Fee Schedule tonight without the usual advance notice. The Master Fee Schedule sets what residents pay for permits, inspections, and city services. City rules normally require agenda items be posted days ahead, but urgent matters can be added same-day.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

Added an urgency agenda item regarding the Master Fee Schedule, and adopted Ordinance No. 15-14

Moved by: Mayor McLaughlinSeconded by: Councilmember Butt
Passed

5 to 0

Councilmember BoozéAye
Councilmember BatesAye
Mayor McLaughlinAye
Councilmember MyrickAye
Councilmember ButtAye

Authorize annual tax on downtown properties to fund business district improvements

Macdonald Avenue

In Plain English

The Downtown Richmond Property and Business Improvement District collects money from downtown property owners to pay for extra services like cleaning, security, and marketing. Property owners in the district voted to create this special tax several years ago. The city must formally approve the annual assessment each year to collect the funds.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

Adopted Resolution No. 64-14

Moved by: Councilmember ButtSeconded by: Councilmember Myrick
Passed

6 to 0

Councilmember BoozéAye
Councilmember BatesAye
Mayor McLaughlinAye
Councilmember MyrickAye
Vice Mayor BecklesAye
Councilmember ButtAye

Authorize special property tax assessments for unpaid city fines and cleanup costs

Police & Community Safety

In Plain English

Some property owners owe the city money for code violations, cleanup costs, and foreclosure fines but haven't paid their bills. If approved, the city can add these unpaid amounts to property tax bills as special assessments. Property owners would then pay the debt through their annual property taxes instead of separate invoices.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

Closed the public hearing

Moved by: Councilmember ButtSeconded by: Councilmember Myrick
Passed

7 to 0

Councilmember BoozéAye
Councilmember BatesAye
Mayor McLaughlinAye
Councilmember MyrickAye
Vice Mayor BecklesAye
Councilmember ButtAye
Councilmember RogersAye

Adopted Resolution No. 65-14

Moved by: Councilmember ButtSeconded by: Vice Mayor Beckles
Passed

7 to 0

Councilmember BoozéAye
Councilmember BatesAye
Mayor McLaughlinAye
Councilmember MyrickAye
Vice Mayor BecklesAye
Councilmember ButtAye
Councilmember RogersAye

Limit time councilmembers have to ask questions during meetings

5-2Police & Community Safety

In Plain English

The city council currently has no formal time limits on how long individual members can speak or ask questions during meetings. This proposal would set specific time restrictions for councilmember comments and questioning. If approved, meetings could move faster but individual councilmembers would have less time to discuss issues.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

To allow an initial 5 minutes for questions and answers; 5 minutes for comments or questions after the speakers; and two floating 5-minute sessions

Moved by: Councilmember ButtSeconded by: Mayor McLaughlin
Passed

5 to 2

Councilmember BoozéNay
Councilmember BatesNay
Mayor McLaughlinAye
Vice Mayor BecklesAye
Councilmember MyrickAye
Councilmember ButtAye
Councilmember RogersAye

Urge county to take over Doctor's Medical Center operations

4-2Political Statements

In Plain English

Doctor's Medical Center currently operates independently in San Pablo. The city wants Contra Costa County to absorb the hospital into its public health system. If the county agrees, this could stabilize the hospital's finances and ensure continued medical services for local residents.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

Adopted Resolution No. 70-14

Moved by: Vice Mayor BecklesSeconded by: Councilmember Myrick
Passed

4 to 2

Councilmember BoozéNay
Councilmember BatesNay
Mayor McLaughlinAye
Vice Mayor BecklesAye
Councilmember MyrickAye
Councilmember ButtAbsent
Councilmember RogersAye

Contracts(1 item)

Hire Pacific States Environmental to clean up contaminated Point Molate naval site

4-3Environmental Justice

In Plain English

Point Molate is a former Navy fuel depot with soil and groundwater contamination from decades of fuel storage. The city needs specialized contractors to remove hazardous materials and clean up environmental damage. Pacific States Environmental will handle the remediation work required before any future development can happen.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

That this matter is held over until the full presentation in September

Moved by: Vice Mayor BecklesSeconded by: Mayor McLaughlin
Failed

To adopt the staff recommendations

Moved by: Councilmember ButtSeconded by: Councilmember Boozé
Passed

4 to 3

Councilmember BoozéAye
Councilmember BatesAye
Mayor McLaughlinNay
Councilmember MyrickNay
Vice Mayor BecklesNay
Councilmember ButtAye
Councilmember RogersAye

Zoning(1 item)

Continue public hearing on Chevron refinery upgrade permits

2-5Chevron & the Refinery

In Plain English

Chevron wants to modernize its Richmond refinery and needs city permits to proceed. The city completed an environmental study of the project's impacts. Residents can speak at this continued hearing before the council votes on whether to approve the permits.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

To adopt staff recommendations

Moved by: Councilmember BatesSeconded by: Councilmember Boozé
Passed

5 to 0

Councilmember BoozéAye
Councilmember BatesAye
Mayor McLaughlinAbstain
Councilmember MyrickAye
Vice Mayor BecklesAbstain
Councilmember ButtAye
Councilmember RogersAye

To uphold the Planning Commission's decision

Moved by: Mayor McLaughlinSeconded by: Vice Mayor Beckles
Failed

2 to 5

Councilmember BoozéNay
Councilmember BatesNay
Mayor McLaughlinAye
Vice Mayor BecklesAye
Councilmember MyrickNay
Councilmember ButtNay
Councilmember RogersNay

To uphold the Planning Commission's decision and include $27 million to help keep Doctor's Medical Center open

Moved by: Vice Mayor BecklesSeconded by: Mayor McLaughlin
Failed

3 to 4

Councilmember BoozéNay
Councilmember BatesNay
Mayor McLaughlinAye
Vice Mayor BecklesAye
Councilmember MyrickNay
Councilmember ButtNay
Councilmember RogersAye

Amendment to the original motion that the council support ShorePower for all ships that are docked at the longwharf

Moved by: Mayor McLaughlinSeconded by: Vice Mayor Beckles
Failed

2 to 5

Councilmember BoozéNay
Councilmember BatesNay
Mayor McLaughlinAye
Vice Mayor BecklesAye
Councilmember MyrickNay
Councilmember ButtNay
Councilmember RogersNay

To call for the question and vote on the original motion

Moved by: Councilmember BatesSeconded by: Councilmember Boozé
Passed

To end debate

Moved by: Councilmember BoozéSeconded by: Councilmember Bates
Passed

5 to 2

Councilmember BoozéAye
Councilmember BatesAye
Mayor McLaughlinNay
Vice Mayor BecklesNay
Councilmember MyrickAye
Councilmember ButtAye
Councilmember RogersAye

To reconsider the vote to end debate for the purpose of allowing the City Manager to explain the details of the Community Benefits Agreement

Moved by: Councilmember RogersSeconded by: Councilmember Myrick
Passed

5 to 1

Councilmember BoozéAye
Councilmember BatesAye
Mayor McLaughlinNay
Vice Mayor BecklesAbsent
Councilmember MyrickAye
Councilmember ButtAye
Councilmember RogersAye

Approved as a group without individual discussion.

Agenda Motion 1Motion to Hear Item G-5 FirstF-18Minutes ApprovalItem Move MotionMotion to Move Item J-1