Tuesday, May 21, 2013

Presiding: Mayor McLaughlin · Called to order: 7:16 p.m. · 8 items · 35 votes · 13 public comments

What happened

  • Rejected contract with Bay Area Fireworks for July 3rd fireworks show at Marina Bay Park.
  • Approved hiring law firm Cotchett, Pitre & McCarthy for lawsuit 5-2 (Myrick, Rogers dissenting).
  • Approved supporting campaign to remove commercial properties from Proposition 13 4-2 (Bates, Boozé dissenting).
  • Approved refinancing up to $45 million in city bonds to reduce interest costs.
  • Approved 24 routine items including $175,000 for North Richmond Ballfield lighting and $413,000 tunnel grant.

Auto-generated summary from agenda items and vote records

View official: Minutes

Attendance

Corky Boozé(Present)
Nat Bates(Present)
Gayle McLaughlin(Present)
Jovanka Beckles(Absent)
Jael Myrick(Present)
Tom Butt(Present)
Jim Rogers(Present)
8 substantive items · 24 consent

Contracts(4 items)

Approve 3-year lease with Native American Health Center for city property

Macdonald Avenue

In Plain English

The Native American Health Center wants to lease city-owned property at 2566 Macdonald Avenue. The city currently owns this building but the health center would operate services there. If approved, the lease runs for 3 years and brings the property into active use.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

Approve the agreement

Moved by: Councilmember BecklesSeconded by: Councilmember Rogers
Passed

7 to 0

McLaughlinAye
MyrickAye
ButtAye
BoozéAye
BatesAye
BecklesAye
RogersAye

Hire BioMax Environmental Services to monitor hydrogen sulfide gas levels

Chevron & the Refinery

In Plain English

The city needs a contractor available to test for hydrogen sulfide, a toxic gas that smells like rotten eggs and can be dangerous in high concentrations. BioMax would provide monitoring services when called upon. The contract ensures the city can quickly respond to gas complaints or safety concerns.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

Approve the contract

Moved by: Councilmember MyrickSeconded by: Councilmember Rogers
Passed

7 to 0

McLaughlinAye
MyrickAye
ButtAye
BoozéAye
BatesAye
BecklesAye
RogersAye

Approve contract with Bay Area Fireworks for July 3rd show at Marina Bay Park

Ford Point & Richmond Village

In Plain English

The city plans to host a fireworks display on July 3rd at Marina Bay Park. Bay Area Fireworks would provide and operate the fireworks show. The contract amount was not specified in the agenda materials.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

Approve the contract for $26,000 for 2013, 2014, and 2015

Moved by: Councilmember BatesSeconded by: Vice Mayor Boozé
Passed

6 to 0

McLaughlinAye
MyrickAbstain
ButtAye
BoozéAye
BatesAye
BecklesAye
RogersAye

Substitute motion that the amounts for 2014 and 2015 not be approved

Moved by: Councilmember Rogers
Failed

Hire law firm Cotchett, Pitre & McCarthy to file lawsuit on contingent-fee basis

2-5Legal Services Agreement

In Plain English

The city plans to file a civil lawsuit but has not disclosed the target or claims. Cotchett, Pitre & McCarthy will handle the case and only get paid if the city wins or settles. If approved, the city pays no upfront legal fees but gives the firm a percentage of any money recovered.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

Hold Item G-37 over for 30 days

Moved by: Vice Mayor BoozéSeconded by: Councilmember Bates
Failed

2 to 5

McLaughlinNay
MyrickNay
ButtNay
BoozéAye
BatesAye
BecklesNay
RogersNay

Approve the agreement

Moved by: Mayor McLaughlinSeconded by: Councilmember Beckles
Failed

Engage Chevron in mediation with understanding that if settlement not reached litigation will be filed, and contract approval take place 30 days from today if no settlement reached

Moved by: Councilmember RogersSeconded by: Councilmember Myrick
Passed

5 to 2

McLaughlinAye
MyrickAye
ButtAye
BoozéNay
BatesNay
BecklesAye
RogersAye

Second substitute motion to hire the firm on a contingency basis and continue the mediation process

Moved by: Mayor McLaughlinSeconded by: Councilmember Beckles
Failed

3 to 3

BatesNay
McLaughlinAye
MyrickAbstain
ButtAye
BoozéNay
BecklesAye
RogersNay

End debate

Moved by: Councilmember BatesSeconded by: Vice Mayor Boozé
Passed

5 to 2

BatesAye
McLaughlinAye
MyrickNay
ButtAye
BoozéAye
BecklesAye
RogersNay

Governance(1 item)

Adopt formal decision supporting campaign to remove commercial properties from Proposition 13

4-2Political Statements

In Plain English

Proposition 13 limits property tax increases on all properties to 2% per year, even when market values rise much higher. This keeps commercial property taxes artificially low compared to residential properties. The city council would formally support a statewide campaign to change this law for businesses only.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

Extend the meeting for one hour

Moved by: Councilmember RogersSeconded by: Councilmember Myrick
Failed

Complete the current item and adjourn the meeting

Moved by: Councilmember Boozé
Failed

Extend the meeting to 11:30 p.m.

Moved by: Mayor McLaughlinSeconded by: Councilmember Beckles
Passed

Adopt Resolution No. 47-13

Moved by: Mayor McLaughlinSeconded by: Councilmember Beckles
Passed

4 to 2

BatesNay
MyrickAbstain
ButtAye
BoozéNay
McLaughlinAye
BecklesAye
RogersAye

Budget(2 items)

Refinance up to $45 million in city bonds to reduce interest costs

Bond Refunding

In Plain English

The city wants to refinance existing bonds, similar to refinancing a mortgage when rates drop. This could lower the city's annual debt payments and free up money for other services. The $45 million represents the maximum amount they could refinance, not new debt.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

Adopt Resolution No. 44-13

Moved by: Councilmember BatesSeconded by: Councilmember Butt
Passed

6 to 0

McLaughlinAye
MyrickAye
ButtAye
BoozéAye
BatesAye
RogersAye

Transfer $10,000 from insurance money for Martin Luther King Jr. Community Center design plans

MLK Community Center

In Plain English

The city received insurance money after damage to the Martin Luther King Jr. Community Center. Officials want to use $10,000 of those funds to hire architects for initial design concepts. If approved, the city moves forward with planning repairs or renovations to the community center.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

Approve the transfer and appropriation

Moved by: Vice Mayor BoozéSeconded by: Councilmember Rogers
Passed

7 to 0

McLaughlinAye
MyrickAye
ButtAye
BoozéAye
BatesAye
BecklesAye
RogersAye

Appointments(1 item)

Appoint and reappoint members to 4 city committees

Point Molate

In Plain English

The city fills vacant seats on committees that advise the council on housing, planning, aging services, and Point Molate development. These volunteer positions help shape city policies in their areas. Committee members typically serve 2-year terms and meet monthly to review proposals and make recommendations.

Auto-generated summary. Source: official agenda documents.

Votes

Vote on each appointment individually

Moved by: Vice Mayor Boozé
Failed

Approve the appointments and reappointments

Moved by: Mayor McLaughlinSeconded by: Councilmember Butt
Passed

6 to 0

McLaughlinAye
MyrickAbsent
ButtAye
BoozéAye
BatesAye
BecklesAye
RogersAye

Approved as a group without individual discussion.